{
  "status": "The tenth trial passes all nineteen functional criteria, with twenty-one Independent and three Assisted stages. One of four tasks passes every handoff stage. The complete handoff gate remains unmet.",
  "current": "junior-round10",
  "rounds": [
    {
      "id": "junior-round1",
      "disposition": "Failed on author verification. The prototype loads new standalone styling instead of extending the documentation recipe; tab arrows do not work, the named feature flag has no implementation, and prompt text is inserted as executable HTML. The implementer's six passing checks did not cover those requirements.",
      "evidence": "evidence/junior-round1/author-verification.json",
      "originalReportRetained": true
    },
    {
      "id": "junior-round2",
      "disposition": "Failed on independent verification. All four task passes were rejected: 5 claimed stages passed verification, 10 failed and 9 remained unverified. Findings include an impossible selection timestamp, inactive inherited controls, clipped responsive content, absent reusable rendering API and broken clipboard recovery.",
      "evidence": "evidence/junior-round2/independent-verification/report.json",
      "originalReportRetained": true
    },
    {
      "id": "junior-round3",
      "disposition": "Failed on independent verification. The implementation dropped navigation and API details, did not fulfill the claimed copy fallback or all transient states, and recorded task selection after implementation had begun. The reusable factory and several behavior checks passed, but none of the four full tasks passed.",
      "evidence": "evidence/junior-round3/independent-verification/report.json",
      "originalReportRetained": true
    },
    {
      "id": "junior-round4",
      "disposition": "Failed on independent verification. All four tasks failed; 11 of 19 acceptance criteria passed and 6 of 24 stage claims passed. The implementation did not restore default code, omitted the complete docs shell and a reusable API, clipped guidance on narrow screens and provided no visible loading state. The task seal predates implementation edits, but conflicts with the implementer's reported start time.",
      "evidence": "evidence/junior-round4/independent-verification/report.json",
      "originalReportRetained": true
    },
    {
      "id": "junior-round5",
      "disposition": "Failed on independent verification. All four tasks failed; 11 of 19 acceptance criteria passed and 5 of 24 stages were Independent. The retry tab lacked keyboard access, the new page had broken search and TOC links plus unsupported API details, and the outcome pattern lacked a caller API and valid panel relationships. Local state, race and narrow-layout behavior passed its observable checks. Frozen input and sealed output hashes remained intact.",
      "evidence": "evidence/junior-round5/independent-verification/report.json",
      "originalReportRetained": true
    },
    {
      "id": "junior-round6",
      "disposition": "Failed complete-task verification. Fifteen of 19 acceptance criteria passed and 11 of 24 stages were Independent; none of the four tasks passed every required stage. The submission used the supplied callable component API, but did not extend the existing code example in context, retained an incomplete shell, guessed a request/result shape and exposed a light-theme contrast defect. The cross-cutting task passed all five behavior criteria but lacked complete Verify and Explain evidence. The verifier runtime retained prior-round context; all findings were re-derived from this sealed output and fresh tests. Input and output manifests remained intact.",
      "evidence": "evidence/junior-round6/independent-verification/report.json",
      "originalReportRetained": true
    },
    {
      "id": "junior-round7",
      "disposition": "Failed complete-task verification in a fresh independent context. Sixteen of 19 acceptance criteria passed and 8 of 24 stages were Independent; all four complete tasks failed. The new page lacked an existing discovery link, the outcome pattern was a hard-coded singleton whose second instance changed the first, and an Empty option did not handle an empty outcome collection. The retry variant and all five cross-cutting behavior criteria passed their observable checks, but the component anatomy and import were incomplete. The implementer's ten-check script passed on reexecution while omitting material acceptance evidence, so all Verify stages remained Blocked. Both frozen and submitted manifests remained intact.",
      "evidence": "evidence/junior-round7/independent-verification/report.json",
      "originalReportRetained": true
    },
    {
      "id": "junior-round8",
      "disposition": "Failed complete-task verification. Twelve of 19 acceptance criteria passed; 8 stages were Independent, 15 Assisted and 1 Blocked, with 0 of 4 complete tasks. The new page lacked incoming discovery and a complete docs shell. It used an undocumented exception name, ignored its caller request, and omitted tab-panel relationships. The empty fixture used success semantics. Unrelated tabs also triggered an inherited keyboard-handler error. The implementer's 19-check replay exited 0 but omitted material requirements, including the retry page. Every input, archive, reconstruction, changed-file and output seal remained intact. The verifier disclosed historic summary text in a tool response; its exact source could not be established, weakening clean-context isolation. Original observations and the provenance correction are retained.",
      "evidence": "evidence/junior-round8/independent-verification/report.json",
      "originalReportRetained": true
    },
    {
      "id": "junior-round9",
      "disposition": "Failed complete-task verification. Seventeen of nineteen acceptance criteria passed. Twelve stages were Independent and twelve Blocked; none of the four tasks passed every stage. Three tasks met their functional criteria. The reusable pattern still owns hard-coded data and has no caller API or executable empty-collection branch. The original verification replay exits 0 but substitutes prose checks for those behaviors and omits required checks. Source-location records are incomplete, and timestamp fields that predate the trial do not establish contemporaneous planning. The frozen input and output seals remain intact. This trial requested Terra high instead of the default Luna medium; the model escalation does not replace earlier evidence.",
      "evidence": "evidence/junior-round9/independent-verification/report.json",
      "originalReportRetained": true
    },
    {
      "id": "junior-round10",
      "disposition": "Separate verification passes all 19 functional criteria. Twenty-one stages are Independent and three are Assisted; one of four tasks passes every stage. The implementer did not run all named tab-key, lifecycle, safety, retry-context and offline checks before handing off. The independent verifier ran those checks successfully, which establishes behavior but does not retroactively make the implementer's verification independent. All input/output manifests, seven changed files and the 389-file reconstruction remain intact. This context-limited trial requested Sol high and does not establish default-model or human junior usability. The current extension guidance was clarified after this sealed trial; that wording has not had a new handoff trial.",
      "evidence": "evidence/junior-round10/independent-verification/report.json",
      "originalReportRetained": true
    }
  ],
  "updatedAt": "2026-09-18T22:04:12.960Z"
}